Homeowners insurance used to be a box you checked near the end of a purchase. Today it can decide whether a deal closes at all.
If you are buying, selling, or simply owning a home in Santa Barbara or Montecito, insurance belongs at the front of the conversation. The market is still under real strain, but it is also changing faster than it has in decades. The coming months bring three dates worth knowing: a 29.1% FAIR Plan rate increase on October 15, an election on November 3 that will choose California's next Insurance Commissioner, and a new statewide smoke damage law that takes effect January 1.
Below is where things stand on the four fronts that matter most to homeowners and buyers: availability, rising costs, consumer protection, and the impact on real estate. Figures are current as of September 30, 2026.
Insurance Availability: Fewer Doors, but Some Are Reopening
Coverage is still hard to find in high-risk areas, but the trend is no longer only downward.
The clearest measure of the problem is the California FAIR Plan, the state's insurer of last resort. It held 696,562 policies as of June 2026, up 8% from September 2025 and up 157% from September 2022. Its total exposure reached $768 billion. Stanford researchers found that FAIR Plan enrollment has nearly tripled, from under 2% to about 5% of homes.
The FAIR Plan is designed as a safety net, not a full homeowners policy. It provides basic fire coverage, with residential dwelling limits capped at $3 million, and generally leaves out liability, water damage and theft. Most FAIR Plan customers pair it with a separate "difference in conditions" (DIC) policy. For a Montecito estate valued well above the cap, coverage often has to be layered across several policies.
Santa Barbara knows this story. After the Thomas Fire and the 2018 debris flow, foothill homeowners in Santa Barbara and Montecito reported nonrenewal notices and difficulty finding traditional coverage.
What is changing. Under the state's Sustainable Insurance Strategy, insurers may now use forward-looking wildfire catastrophe models and count reinsurance costs in their rates. In exchange, they must commit to writing policies in wildfire-distressed areas. One route requires writing at least 85% of a carrier's statewide market share in those areas, or growing there by at least 5%.
There are early signs it is working. FAIR Plan new business is down 25% compared with last year, and carriers including Mercury and CSAA have announced plans to expand. As one broker told KQED, there are markets today that did not exist a month ago.
What is still unresolved. Nobody has a final count of how many policies have actually been written. Consumer Watchdog estimates insurers have committed to 12,189 additional policies since January 2025, based on rate filings rather than completed sales. The Department of Insurance calls that analysis incomplete and says it will publish its own data.
Rising Costs: Premiums Are Climbing, and Unevenly
The next big number arrives October 15, when the FAIR Plan's 29.1% average rate increase takes effect for its 675,000-plus customers. It is the largest increase in the plan's recent history, down from the 35.8% it requested. Homes in high wildfire risk areas may pay far more, and some will see the wildfire portion of their premium double. Lower-risk urban homes may see little change or even a reduction.
More broadly, Stanford researchers found California homeowners insurance premiums are up 84% since 2020. Insurers point to higher rebuilding costs, more expensive reinsurance and recent wildfire losses.
Private carriers are a mixed picture. Recent approvals and filings range from low single digits to 40%:
- California FAIR Plan: 29.1% average (35.8% requested). New and renewal policies from October 15, 2026.
- Farmers: 1.5% average (6.99% requested), about 915,000 homeowners. Renewals after September 15.
- CSAA and Mercury: about 6.9% average; Mercury's individual changes ranged from a 10% decrease to a 60% increase. CSAA from March 15, Mercury from July.
- Grange: 40% on standard homeowners policies. Effective January 1, 2026.
- State Farm General: 17% for homeowners, made final by a July 2026 order. In effect since June 2025.
Two practical points follow. First, your premium depends heavily on your individual address and your home's wildfire risk, so statewide averages tell you little. Second, mitigation now pays. Mercury has said home hardening discounts can cut the wildfire portion of a premium by up to a third, and CSAA guarantees renewal for homeowners who obtain an Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety certificate.
For buyers, the FAIR Plan plus a DIC policy is a real cost to budget for. Ask for actual quotes early rather than relying on the seller's current premium.
Consumer Protection: New Rules After a Claim, and a Rate Process Under Debate
The biggest recent change protects homeowners after a wildfire, and the bigger argument is about how rates get approved.
On September 15, Governor Newsom signed AB 1795, the Smoke Damage Recovery Act, which the Department of Insurance calls the nation's first enforceable standards for investigating, testing and restoring smoke-damaged homes. It follows the Eaton and Palisades fires, which produced more than 13,000 claims on standing homes with smoke damage. Among its provisions:
- A presumption that smoke damage inside a wildfire impact zone came from that fire
- Insurers pay for necessary testing and sampling
- Additional living expense benefits cannot end until a qualifying home is restored and safe to occupy
- Set timelines for inspections and claim handling
- Policyholders keep the right to choose their restoration contractor
- Training requirements for adjusters handling smoke claims
A companion bill, AB 1642, directs the state to set standards for testing wildfire contaminants. The package takes effect January 1, with some technical standards phased in through 2029.
On nonrenewals, state law requires that a residential nonrenewal notice include information on the Department's Home Insurance Finder and the FAIR Plan. The FAIR Plan also runs a clearinghouse meant to move policyholders back into the regular market, where admitted insurers get the first 30 days to offer coverage.
The rate debate. The Sustainable Insurance Strategy also changed rate review, with faster timelines and more public access to intervenor filings. Supporters call it the biggest modernization since Proposition 103 passed in 1988. Critics, including Consumer Watchdog, argue that rate increases are moving faster than new coverage: its review found 10 insurers seeking about $571 million in increases under the new rules, and only five committed to writing more policies.
That same group helped negotiate the State Farm settlement, which limited the homeowners increase to 17% instead of the 30% the insurer originally sought.
The election. Commissioner Ricardo Lara is term-limited, so voters will choose his successor on November 3. The top two finishers in the June primary were state Senator Ben Allen and former San Francisco Supervisor Jane Kim, both Democrats.
Allen is running on what he calls a comprehensive approach that brings the state, insurers, builders, local governments and firefighters together on risk reduction. His proposals include a consumer advocate inside the Department of Insurance, requiring insurers to explain claim denials with real-time reporting, and more oversight of the FAIR Plan. He also points to bills he authored requiring insurers to pay claims without detailed inventories and extending notice periods for nonrenewals.
Kim has proposed "natural disaster insurance for all," modeled on a New Zealand program, in which the state would guarantee fire and flood coverage while private insurers cover other risks. Her shorter-term priorities include public dashboards showing insurers' spending and claims records and a more transparent FAIR Plan.
Whoever wins will approve or reject the rate requests that shape what your neighbors and clients pay.
The Real Estate Impact: Insurance Is Now Part of the Offer
Insurance now affects whether a buyer can close, what they can afford each month, and how fast a deal moves.
A 2024 California Association of Realtors member survey found that 13% of respondents had a transaction fall out of escrow because a buyer could not find insurance, up from 6.9% the year before. Nearly a third said their most recent buyers had trouble getting coverage, and about one in five ended up on the FAIR Plan. Since lenders require proof of insurance before funding a loan, a missing policy can stall or end a purchase.
Cost matters as much as access. A premium that doubles late in escrow changes the monthly payment a buyer qualified for. One Bay Area Realtor leader told NBC that finding out in the last 10 days can push a buyer into crisis mode and recommended shopping for coverage before even making an offer.
For Buyers
- Start insurance quotes before you write the offer, especially for hillside, foothill or high fire hazard properties
- Work with an independent insurance broker who can shop several carriers and price a FAIR Plan plus DIC combination
- Ask for a real quote or binder, not a rough estimate, and get it well inside your contingency period
- Request the seller's current declarations page and claims history so you know what the home has been insured for and at what cost
- Budget the full insurance cost into your monthly payment, the same way you would property taxes
For Sellers
- Gather your current policy, recent premiums and any claims history before you list
- Document wildfire mitigation such as roofing, ember-resistant vents and defensible space, since these can lower premiums and improve insurability
- Expect buyers to ask about insurance early, and be ready to answer
Insurance is one more reason to work with an agent who knows the specific street, not just the zip code. Fire risk, hillside exposure and carrier appetite can differ from one block to the next in Santa Barbara, Montecito, Goleta and Carpinteria.
The Bottom Line
California's insurance market is not fixed, but it is moving. More carriers are returning, the FAIR Plan's growth is slowing, and new claim protections are on the way. Costs, meanwhile, keep rising, and the people setting the rules will change after November 3.
For anyone buying or selling in Santa Barbara or Montecito, the practical answer is preparation: understand your property's insurance profile early, get real quotes, and build that time into your plan. If you are thinking about a move and want to talk through how insurance could affect your timeline or budget, I am glad to help, and I can connect you with trusted local insurance brokers.
This post is general information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Please speak with a licensed insurance professional about your specific property.
Curtis Swan II
(805) 607-9709
Find my five-star reviews on RateMyAgent.
